If you work at David Jones, this is a strange Christmas. Nineteen of its 38 stores will close by the end of the year. Some team members learnt their store was closing at about the same time the news broke in the media. Others are still waiting to find out what a smaller David Jones means for them. In between, they’re wrapping gifts, processing returns and greeting every customer who walks in, some of them in front of shelves that suppliers have already stripped.
Most of the conversation about saving David Jones is about leases, lenders and buyers. That matters. But the people who will decide whether customers come back are the ones on the floor right now.
The receivers have told staff it’s business as usual and that wages and entitlements will be paid. That’s necessary. It isn’t enough.
Right now, David Jones has three groups of team members. There are those who have already left. There are those being asked to give their best for a few more weeks before they lose their jobs. And there are those who, at this stage, believe they have a job beyond Christmas, while they watch colleagues leave. All three are watching how people are treated, and the ones still on the floor are looking for the same thing: honesty, certainty and a reason to keep caring.
I’ve long believed your employees are also customers, customers of your leadership. A team can’t deliver an experience it doesn’t live itself, and when the experience inside a business falls apart, customers feel it within weeks.
The good news is that customers haven’t given up. According to statements from the receivers, foot traffic and sales have been at record levels since the collapse. Every one of those customers was served by someone who didn’t know whether they’d have a job in the new year.
What I learnt leading teams through a crisis
I joined Volkswagen Group Australia days after the emissions scandal broke. Our teams and our dealer partner teams copped the anger of customers who felt let down, over something they had no part in. One of the simplest things I did was write thank-you cards to team members, so they knew we were on this journey together. It sounds small. It wasn’t.
But thank-you cards don’t rebuild a brand. That takes a new service standard, and every service standard starts with an experience promise: what customers can count on from you, every time. The promise only works if team members live it, and if it gives them what they need to deliver the standards that sit underneath it. David Jones doesn’t have either yet. Whoever runs it next will need to work both out, with the people on the floor, not for them. When everything feels uncertain, people want to know what great looks like.
Earlier, at Target, I took over a team where turnover sat between 20 and 30 per cent. By the time we’d rebuilt it, turnover was down to 5 per cent. None of that came from a poster on the wall. It came from clarity, consistency and leaders who showed up.
Four things team members need right now
- Certainty, even when there’s no news. During a product-safety crisis at Target, I sent an update at 8am every day, even on the days there was nothing new to say. In any crisis, the first job of a leader is to create milestones people can count on. Even “no change since yesterday” tells people they haven’t been forgotten.
- Hearing it from their leaders first. No team member should learn their store is closing from a news alert. If the news is going to break, tell your people first, face to face.
- Clear permission to look after customers. Gift cards, returns and lay-bys are where trust is won or lost right now. Tell team members exactly what they can do to fix a problem on the spot, then back them when they do it. A customer who watches a team member go looking for permission to honour a gift card stops believing the brand will look after them.
- Respect for the people leaving. The team members who stay will watch closely how those who leave are treated. Thank them publicly, help them find their next role, and honour every entitlement. In a restructure, the exit experience is part of the employee experience.
This isn’t only a David Jones problem. Every business that restructures, merges or cuts costs faces the same choice. The leaders who invest in their people when it’s hardest are the ones whose customers stay.
Whoever ends up owning David Jones will inherit customers wondering if they should still care and a team that has been through the hardest Christmas of their careers. You can’t rebuild the customer experience on top of a broken employee experience.
Every team member who walks onto the floor this week is one experience away from staying, or from deciding they’ve had enough. The same is true in your business.
So my question to every leader running a restructure is simple. What are your people hearing from you today?
