One of the biggest mistakes businesses make is assuming that they understand what customers want without even asking. A customer goes quiet, so we assume everything is going well. Product usage drops, so we assume the customer is losing interest. When a customer raises a complaint, we suddenly label them a churn risk. Someone asks about pricing, and we immediately start thinking about discounts.
Kelly Clarkson’s recent public dispute with Brooklyn store Art of Play is one of the more high-profile examples of the dangers of taking behaviour at face value. Clarkson alleged she was judged on what she could seemingly afford after being offered a cheaper alternative to an expensive item. The store disputed her interpretation, explaining the item wasn’t for sale. While the perspectives differ, the public fallout demonstrates how quickly a misunderstood customer interaction can escalate into a reputational issue.
In customer success, we’re constantly extrapolating the meaning of the most minor behaviours to gauge the health of our relationships. But there’s a difference between recognising a signal and having a true understanding of whether it changes or influences what the customer actually wants from us.
We all make assumptions; that isn’t really a problem. Acting on it before testing whether it’s right is what actually causes issues.
The problem with taking behaviour at face value
Businesses have become increasingly sophisticated at measuring customer engagement. We track product adoption, support tickets, satisfaction scores and renewal likelihood, often using this information to determine which relationships need attention.
The data can tell us what’s happening, but it doesn’t usually explain why. 31% of Australian consumers don’t tell anyone following a bad experience, while 41% reduce or stop spending with a business after a negative interaction. The warning is just as relevant to B2B relationships as it is to consumers: silence isn’t necessarily a sign of satisfaction or dissatisfaction.
A customer who rarely contacts their account manager might be perfectly satisfied. Equally, they might have lost their internal champion, changed strategic priorities or simply stopped seeing value in the partnership. Meanwhile, a customer who regularly raises concerns could be more invested in making the relationship work than someone who never provides feedback.
If we only respond to customers who are vocal about their experiences, we risk overlooking the relationships that need our attention most.
Your smallest customer could become your biggest
I’ve seen firsthand how easily businesses can underestimate customers based on what they look like today. In 2022, I onboarded a customer that was considered a small business at the time. Today, that same organisation has grown to become HiBob’s largest customer in the region. It’s a great reminder that the value of a customer relationship isn’t fixed. Had we assessed that organisation purely on its initial size or commercial value, it would have been easy to underestimate its potential.
This isn’t an isolated experience. I’ve seen similar examples where customers that initially appeared relatively small became significantly more important as their businesses evolved. The lesson for customer success teams is to look beyond the immediate contract and understand where a customer’s business is heading.
Are they expanding into new markets? Hiring rapidly? Facing operational challenges? Planning changes that could fundamentally reshape what they need from you? Those conversations are valuable. I encourage businesses to look at the relationship like an investor would look at investing in stocks, or how a venture capital firm would look at a company trying to scale. Evaluating the bigger picture is always helpful, and prioritising long-term growth can go a long way.
Curiosity is a commercial advantage
Customer relationships usually deteriorate when businesses repeatedly misunderstand their needs. It’s usually an ongoing pattern that leads to dissatisfaction, resulting in disengagement.
The same logic applies to growth opportunities. If we assume smaller customers have limited potential or that quiet customers don’t need attention, we can miss opportunities to build relationships that become more valuable over time.
The longer I’ve worked in Customer Success, the more convinced I’ve become that curiosity is one of the most important commercial skills we have. Metrics help us identify where to look. Experience helps us recognise patterns. Neither replaces the value of asking a customer what’s actually happening in their business and making sure you’re checking in regularly to keep up to date on changes.
Before reacting to the next customer signal, take the time to understand the intent behind it. You might find that they tell you something completely different from what you assumed.
